Essay 2 Introduction The Theaetetus represents one of Plato’s dialogues relating to Plato’s dialogues concerning the natureof knowledge. Theaetetus’ first response to Socrates’ question of definition of knowledge begins with examples of knowledge such as geometry, harmony, arithmetic, and astronomy. Theaetetus suggests a second definition of knowledge in which he outlines that knowledge is true belief. Protagoras understandably pursued to preserve the reality of sense perception. # 1) Explain Protagoras’ position in your own words Protagoras makes a philosophical statement regarding the structure of reality. Protagoras proposes that knowledge is nothing but perception. The definition of knowledge as perception draws from the Protagoras’ position that man is the measure of all things. A relativistic epistemology eventually underpins any positive definitions of knowledge, and, thus, is self-refuting. The proposal that knowledge is perception means that perception is both sufficient and necessary for knowledge. This necessitates that the two conditions are separate and are pertinent in comprehending the objections to the analysis. It is essential to take note an ambiguity within the term perception (employed to refer to perception via the senses) (Zilioli 31). # 2) Give at least three arguments in your own words that Socrates uses to refute Theaetetus or Protagoras. Socrates’ seeks to raise a number of objections against the proposal that man is the measure, that knowledge is perception. The first set of objections direct against the allegation that perception is adequate for knowledge and relates to relativity of perception. The proposal is that, in some instances, such as hot or cold, all perception is effective in that there is no variation between perception and appearance. The second objection to Protagoras’ thesis can be found in Socrates’ two rhetorical questions, whereby, given that Protagoras’ thesis entails that all perceptions are true, it not only bear the allegedly absurd consequence highlighting that animal’s perceptions are not substandard to humans (Lampert 109). This means that if all perceptions were to be true, there cannot be any reason to perceive that animal perceptions are inferior to human perceptions. Socrates considers this situation to be incongruous. Socrates points out a number of problems for any theory regarding perception by highlighting how perceptions differ in one is healthy and when one is ill. This appears to contradict with Protagoras’ dictum that suggests that whatever one perceives is knowledge (Jolley 45). Socrates remedies the situation by highlighting that Socrates who is healthy and the Socrates who is ailing are two distinct subjects. After the first objection and having demonstrated the prima facie truth of Protagoras’ proposal, Socrates proceeds with systematic levying of additional objections to the position. First, Socrates questions why one should perceive that man is the measure, as opposed to some other creature such as a pig. Second, Socrates questions why, if that were the case in which what anyone thinks is true for him, anyone would seek advice of others when each of use is himself the measure of his own wisdom. The third and one of the most significant objections to Protagoras’ centers on ” the table-turning argument,” which makes reference to the effect that Protagoras’ theory suggests that no one is wiser that anyone else (Lampert 110). This objection outlines that if whatever anyone thinks is true, then for those who perceive that Protagoras’ own view is false it follows that Protagoras’ suggestion is false. Notably, this objection does not assault the notion that perception as infallible, instead is assaults the notion that the opinion of judgment that anyone shapes on the grounds of perception is infallible (Zilioli 32). # 3) How do Socrates’ ideas of knowledge seem to differ from those of Protagoras? In the Theaetetus, three possibilities regarding what knowledge is and how individuals come to have it is presented. The first is that knowledge is perception and that people’s perceptions are true, at least to the holders, but illusions or dreams may manifest. Socrates stipulates that Protagoras’ relativistic argument “ man is the measure of all things” implies “ what is true, is what is true for me,” but innumerable others may properly judge the opinion to be false. Socrates is quick to point out that Protagoras had asserted that perception means appearance and that appearances may differ with diverse subjects. Socrates continues to note that if knowledge is perception, then no one can be wiser relative to any other man if every man is the best judge of own sense-perception. Nevertheless, Socrates fails to demonstrate that his theory is entirely plausible (Lee 77). Indeed, Socrates discussion that crests in the table-turning argument appears to be far from the initial example. Socrates acknowledges that the wind might feel chilly to one and not chilly to another. Conclusion Protagoras proposes that knowledge is perception. Sometimes “ perception” appears to means “ immediate sensory awareness,” while in other instances is appears to translate to “ judgments made regarding immediate sensory awareness.” The suggestion “ knowledge represents immediate sensory awareness” is refuted as incoherent, given that knowledge is not to be situated in bodily experiences, but in people reasoning regarding those experiences. Protagoras might have been referring to the relativity of perceptual or empirical observations. Works Cited Jolley, Kelly. “ Made to measure: Socrates’ Exquisite Argument against Protagoras.” Trinity College Dublin 180 (2006): 45-63. Lampert, Laurence. How Philosophy Became Socratic: A Study of Plato’s Protagoras, Charmides, and Republic. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2010. Print. Lee, Mi-Kyoung. Epistemology After Protagoras: Responses to Relativism in Plato, Aristotle, and Democritus. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005. Print. Zilioli, Ugo. Protagoras and the Challenge of Relativism: Plato’s Subtlest Enemy. Aldershot: Ashgate, 2007. Print.
Related Essay Samples
Free brave new world sociology essay sample
In Brave New World, " feelies" are the movies that are shown for the sake of consumption by the masses, which also provide the feelings films are meant to elicit for us. Of all of your dissatisfactions with life, pick ...
Modern day utopia essay
In most descriptions of utopia, there is not the idea of equality that most of us feel would be there. However, for a utopia to truly succeed, it would have to be without many of the material objects that we ...
Philosophy essay on sollicitudo rei socialis
He also wants to pay honor to the original document and to show the value of church teachings because of the " continuity and renewal" of the ideas in the encyclical. In the Originality of the encyclical Populorum Progressio portion, ...
Free war of words article review sample
Henry Louis Gates, Jr.argues in his article War of Words: Critical Race Theory and the First Amendment that there exists a tension between civil rights and civil liberties with specific emphasis on the freedom of speech and hate speech or ...
Dear sir or madam essay example
Kant establishes that a priori knowledge is possible by arguing the mind structures experiences and we can come to know things from this structure. By using the knowledge of synthetic a priori in the concept of geometry, Kant explained that ...
The seventh letter by plato
Plato not only supported Dion who had now decided to change the lives Syracuse's but also accepted Dion's idea of pretending to be a person who does not cares about philosophy, this way they could teach Dionysius the rules of ...
Personal professional ethics
Personal Professional Ethics ' Ethics in safety, compassion and competence for a nurse' Becoming an outstanding nurse is my future dream in career and I am currently pursuing my nursing study in preparation for this. Principal to my profession ...
Ontological argument
So if we cannot add existence as a predicate of God's perfection, as existence is not an actual predicate then the Ontological argument falls on its foundations, as it is fundamental to Anselm that existence is a predicate of God, ...
Example of essay on this seeks to develop a conceptual framework that will get the attention
On the other hand, the aspect of Hallenbach's idea of justice attributes to the trust of the importance of freedom as a manifestation of human dignity. This means that, the aspect of tolerance may not make meaning when correlating it ...
Religious freedom
Many states and corporations have imposed such bans, from the refusal to allow the wearing of the cross in the workplace to the outlawing of the burqa in public places. 18 The aim of rethinking religious freedom is to strengthen, ...
Anger,hatred,powerlessness and connection
Anger, Hatred, Powerlessness And Connection Anger, Hatred, Powerlessness And Connection I and Thou" by Martin Buber This prose is a dialog with one's self about what it means simply to be a person. Gould offers a more healthy approach in ...
Moral philosophy in ‘liar liar’ by paul guay
In this case immorality will entail a violation of the categorical imperative and is therefore not rational. To be straight to the point, it is clear that we are commanded to exercise our wills in a particular manner and not ...
Truthtruth and power
While the reader may be able to make out similarities between Foucault's definition of truth and that which might come from a Marxist; Karl Marx at least took the trouble of keeping alive the struggle, to bring the truth to ...
Choose one step in the memory process: encoding
Retrieved from http://human-factors.arc.nasa.gov/cognition/tutorials/ModelOf/Knowmore1.html [Accessed: 17 March 2014]. Retrieved from http://www.ehow.com/facts_7269925_retroactive-vs_-proactive-interference.html [Accessed: 17 March 2014].
Sociologist karl marx
Macro theories work from the society downward, the society forces the people to change, not the people change society. This theory is different from the other two because instead of working from the society down in a macro prospective, it ...
Emancipation proclamation as a war strategy essay example
The proclamation happened during the American Civil War in 1861 - 1865, where the North went to war with the South, as the eleven states of Confederacy made a withdrawal from the Union in 1860 & 1861, to reunite America, ...
Why is the crowd important in existentialism?
Whenever you are in a crowd the thought is that you can learn from one another, be influenced by one another and Kierkegaard dislikes this because he wants you to be separate from one another. So even in salvation the ...
Three important lessons: plato’s apology
The background of the Apology is that Socrates is being charged with the corruption of the youth and disrespect towards the Gods. He also wishes to emphasize that it is his wisdom and knowledge that make him persecuted, but this ...
Thinking about consciousness by papineau
In the book, Papineau tries to explain the existence of subjective consciousness in the physical world. For example, if one feels thirsty, the thirst is considered the conscious state and the neuronal firing the physical state that together causes the ...
Kierkegaards account of faith
The reconciliation of the knight of Faith with his fate of not getting the princess ever is surpassed by a belief in the absurd, i.e, an amorphous, formless, and intangible feeling based on the fact that through the power of ...
A modest proposal for preventing the children of poor people in ireland, from being a burden on their parents or country, and for making them beneficial to the publick
A Modest Proposal for preventing the children of poor people in Ireland, from being a burden on their parents or country, and for making them beneficial to the public Jonathan Swift's ' Modest Proposal' uses an ironic way of criticizing ...
Summery of chapter 11,12 and 13
Summary of chapter 11, 12 and 13 The three chapters in the book discuss the contemporary theories of philosophy which have been developed and spread in the 20th Century. The arguments presented in the chapters are not so clear and ...
Descartes’ doubt
Descartes asserts that senses are illusionary and hinder the knowledge of the truth. In the second meditation, Descartes explores the truth about the of nature of human mind and body.
Marcuse’s critique of jean paul sartre’s being essay sample
Marcuse points out that this conflict takes the same form as Sartre's account of the " fundamental project," which states that all of our actions are underpinned by the dynamics of the desire of the " for-itself" to dominate completely ...
Morality and survival under stalinism
It forced the populace to participate in a socially acceptable " norm" that reinforced the government's version of the truth. To call into question the official version of events and affairs is to admit to the lie and to one's ...